Inventing Destiny:
Cultural Explorations of US Expansion

Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2019
(UP Kansas) (Amazon) (Barnes and Noble)​

The mythmakers of US expansion have expressed “manifest destiny” in many different ways—and so have its many discontents. A multidisciplinary study that delves into these contrasts and contradictions, Inventing Destiny offers a broad yet penetrating cultural history of nineteenth-century US territorial acquisition—a history that gives voice to the underrepresented actors who significantly complicated US narratives of empire, from Native Americans and Anglo-American women to anti- and non-national expansionists. The contributors—established and emerging scholars from history, American studies, literary studies, art history, and religious studies—make use of source materials and techniques as various as artwork, religion, geospatial analysis, interior colonialism, and storytelling alongside fresh readings of traditional historical texts. In doing so, they seek to illuminate the complexities rather than simplify, to transgress borders rather than redraw them, and to amplify the under-told stories rather than repeat the old ones. Their work identifies and explores the obscure—or obscured—fictions of expansion, seeking a deeper understanding of the mechanisms of culture creation and recognizing those who resisted US territorial aggrandizement. The contributors include myself,  Chad. A. Barbour, Daniel J. Burge, Maria Angela Diaz, Andy Doolen, Gerritt Dirkmaat, Kenneth Haltman, Matthew Johnston, Elana Krischer, Thomas Richards Jr., Sarah L. Roberson, and Laurel Clark Shire.

---

Reviews

Journal of American History
"Taken together, the essays in this volume make the historical account of U.S. expansion more complex, highlighting people and sources that scholars have not always considered central to understanding expansion or resistance to it. As such, it will be useful to scholars and students of nineteenth-century U.S. expansion, and of the American South and West." Eva Payne, University of Mississippi.

Pacific Historical Review
"a collection of diverse and thought-provoking articles that are required reading for not only specialists in nineteenth-century territorial expansion, but also readers interested in religion, women, and Native Americans, among other subjects . . . . This anthology widens and deepens our understanding of expansion in the continental United States over three-quarters of the nineteenth century." Ángel Cortés author of Sectarianism and Orestes Brownson in the American Religious Marketplace (2017).

Western Historical Quarterly
"The volume self-consciously aims to update the 'cultural turn' in studies of U.S. expansion by taking a nuanced, multidisciplinary look at the complex and conflicted ways 'groups and individuals experienced, internalized, and rendered meaningful US territorial acquisition.'" Matthew Herman author of Politics and Aesthetics in Contemporary Native American Literature (2010).

---

About the Cover

See the Elsewheres blog for a brief essay about Frances Flora Palmer's Across the Continent (1868). (Click Here)

Advance Word

“In the most important rethinking of US imperialism and expansionism since Amy Kaplan and Donald Pease’s Cultures of United States Imperialism in 1993, Inventing Destiny: Cultural Explanations of US Expansion provides a complex, multi-faceted, multi-dimensional reconsideration of Manifest Destiny. Moving readers beyond the simplistic narrative of expansionism, the essays in this collection challenge the notion that there is anything simple about Manifest Destiny or American imperialism. Instead, they compellingly demonstrate that seemingly simple rhetorical devices like Manifest Destiny emerge from a complicated network of cultural contexts and represent competing agendas, ideals, and goals."--Gregory Eiselein, Professor and University Distinguished Teaching Scholar Department of English, Kansas State University.

“Readers hoping to learn more about the culture of US expansion need look no further than this compelling interdisciplinary collection. The essays in Inventing Destiny offer fresh perspectives on the contested nature of territorial conquests across the North American continent.”--Amy S. Greenberg, author of A Wicked War: Polk, Clay, Lincoln, and the 1846 U.S. Invasion of Mexico (2012) and Manifest Manhood and the Antebellum American Empire (2005).

“Taking a creative, multidisciplinary approach to the study of American westward expansion, Inventing Destiny challenges scholars to think about the cultural driving forces—including art, literature, gender, and religion—behind the rapid transformation of the nations nineteenth-century frontier.”--William S. Kiser, author of Coast-to-Coast Empire: Manifest Destiny and the New Mexico Borderlands (2018). 

“These eclectic, indeed kaleidoscopic, essays take the story of America’s territorial growth from the Early Republic to the Gilded Age in fresh directions. They reveal we can learn as much about the impulses and limits of US expansion from capsule biographies and microscopic and interdisciplinary analyses of obscure texts, maps, artistic renderings and incidents, as we can learn from the machinations of political leaders and diplomats and the victories and setbacks of national armies. Editor Jimmy Bryan and his fellow authors collectively provide a fascinating cultural take not only on the saga of Americas “Manifest Destiny” on its western and southern borderlands, but also on the particular roles of women and marginalized peoples—especially Native Americans, African Americans, and Mormons—within that process. This volume should appeal to anyone tempted to delve beyond commonplace narratives of nineteenth-century America’s thrust westward and southward.”--Robert E. May, author of Slavery, Race, and Conquest in the Tropics: Lincoln, Douglas, and the Future of Latin America (2013) and Manifest Destiny's Underworld: Filibustering in Antebellum America (2004).

“The disciplinary range on display in these essays is impressive, and the collection shows that while manifest destiny was an expression of domination, no one group dominated the creation of the discourse. The book makes a significance contribution to our understanding of the American West and the American nation.”--Jon T. Coleman, author of Vicious: Wolves and Men in America (2006) and Here Lies Hugh Glass: A Mountain Man, A Bear, and the Rise of the American Nation (2013)